The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) recently rolled out a policy change that could reshape how mortgage lenders evaluate creditworthiness. For the first time, lenders working with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will be allowed to factor in on-time rent payments when reviewing mortgage applications.
This change matters because for millions of renters, especially those who are Black or low-income, rent has long been one of their largest and most consistent financial obligations. But until now, it hasn’t helped them build credit in the way traditional debt products do.
What’s Changing
FHFA oversees Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, the two entities that back most U.S. mortgages. Earlier this year, it approved VantageScore 4.0 for use in loans sold to the GSEs. That move expands which credit scoring models lenders can use and opens the door to include alternative data like rent, utility, and phone bill payments.
Unlike the older FICO models still used in most lending, VantageScore 4.0 is designed to reflect a broader picture of how people manage money. That’s especially important for applicants who haven’t had access to credit cards, student loans, or other traditional credit lines.
Why It Matters
According to the Urban Institute, around 50 million Americans have too little credit history to generate a traditional score, and more than 20 million are completely “credit invisible.” These gaps fall hardest on Black and Latino households. This policy has the potential to move the needle. It gives lenders a way to recognize financial responsibility beyond the narrow lens of traditional credit, offering more people a real shot at qualifying for a home loan.
Why VantageScore 4.0 Is Different
For decades, mortgage underwriting has relied on FICO models that weren’t built to reflect the financial habits of renters or low-income households. VantageScore 4.0 was created to change that by incorporating rent and utility payments and weighing them alongside traditional credit data.
However, the new score won’t help unless lenders start using it and rent payments actually get reported to the credit bureaus. That’s a separate challenge. Most small landlords don’t report rent data, and many renters aren’t aware of how or whether their payments are counted.
What We’re Watching
As this policy rolls out, we’ll be keeping an eye on four key issues:
- Lender adoption – Will VantageScore 4.0 gain traction, or will FICO remain the default?
- Rent reporting – Will systems and incentives emerge to help landlords report payments consistently?
- Impact on access – Are more mortgage approvals happening for renters who were previously locked out?
- Role of CDFIs – How can CDFIs help renters understand their options and advocate for equitable implementation?
The Bottom Line
Recognizing rent payments in mortgage underwriting is a practical, long-overdue step. It aligns the credit system a little more closely with how people actually live, and that’s a move toward fairness. But good ideas don’t always lead to real change.
We’ve seen policies stall before, not because they lacked potential, but because adoption was uneven or the systems around them weren’t ready. This one will take more than a rule change. It’ll require coordination across lenders, landlords, credit bureaus, and housing advocates to make sure the benefits actually reach the people it was designed to serve.
Whether that happens depends on what comes next and who stays committed to making it work.